Book Review: The Dangerous Passion by David Buss

by | Mar 5, 2024 | Celebrity News | 0 comments

Who Is David Buss, and What Is Evolutionary Psychology? 

David Buss is an evolutionary psychologist who teaches at the University of Texas, appears on podcasts, writes books, and is one of the founders of evolutionary psychology. Evolutionary psychology is a field that examines the evolutionary purpose of human behavior. For example, it’s theorized that humans overindulge in sugary foods because our more primal ancestors often binged on fruit in the summer, knowing that there was likely to be a scarcity of food in the winter. There are, Buss theorizes, evolutionary purposes for jealousy too. Ensuring that the children you’re providing for are your biological offspring, or that the person providing you with food and shelter isn’t about to bail, were likely very useful to our ancestors, given that they didn’t lead the luxurious lives that we do. 

The Bad News First 

This book could be misinterpreted if it falls into the wrong hands, particularly the hands of someone who is consumed with jealousy, as they may use that as an excuse to continue emotionally and physically abusive behavior. On that note, this book was written over 20 years ago when we were less concerned about social issues such as victim blaming. Unfortunately, Buss does not spend a lot of time holding the perpetrators accountable for their abusive behavior. While it’s clear that he certainly does not condone such behavior, the wrong person may get the idea that they can simply write off their jealous or controlling behavior as a product of evolution.                                

How Much Jealousy Is Okay? 

“He who is not jealous is not in love.” While jealousy can lead to big trouble, a complete lack of jealousy in any and all situations can also be a signal that the relationship isn’t super meaningful to the non-jealous party. Stalking, controlling and possessive behaviors, and violence are always unacceptable behaviors, no matter what the circumstances are. And these unacceptable behaviors can be the result of jealousy. Your partner should never behave in an abusive manner toward you. On the other hand, your spouse shouldn’t be totally fine with you spending a week in Miami with their ex either. Buss argues that some protective jealousy—reasonable jealousy, if you will—is necessary in order to protect the relationship. So, if your spouse’s tropical vacation with their ex is making you feel the green-eyed monster, just know that you’re not alone and you’re not crazy—but you are responsible for conducting yourself in a reasonable manner. If you need to resort to controlling and/or abusive tactics to keep your jealousy at bay, that may be a sign that it’s time to leave the relationship and look into therapy. 

The Evolutionary Advantage to Jealousy 

Buss argues that there’s an evolutionary advantage that causes jealousy, specifically caused by mate-value discrepancy.  Charles Darwin himself came up with the idea of mate-value, but Buss expanded on Darwin’s theory by talking about mate-guarding in relation to mate-value. As in-human as it might sound, Darwin theorized that people carried value regarding their ability to produce offspring with high quality genes. Typically, couples tend to have the same mate-values—however there are some couples who have greatly mismatched mate-values. Buss’s research showed that those who have perceived themselves as lower value than their spouse are more likely to be jealous and employ tactics to keep their partners faithful.       

Is It Worth a Read? 

Well, maybe. Buss’s theory is that jealousy has an evolutionary purpose and that is to ensure paternity (for men) and to protect the relationship (for both genders). Because of this, his book focuses on situations where jealousy is rational—think back to the example of your partner attending a tropical vacation with their ex: if you care about the relationship at all, you probably would feel some jealousy in that situation. The problems begin when readers who have jealous tendencies that aren’t wholly rational pick up this book. Unfortunately, the content of this book may make them believe that their jealous tendencies are rational and acceptable. They may also confuse this book’s evolutionary reasoning as an endorsement of unacceptable behavior. While this book does not condone abuse, explaining abuse under an evolutionary lens may give those with jealous and abusive tendencies an “out” or an excuse for inexcusable behavior. Again, though this book seeks to explain—not excuse—such behavior, it could be taken the wrong way by the wrong person. It could also make a person who already has jealous tendencies even more paranoid. If you’re interested in evolutionary psychology, and why humans may have adapted to feel jealous in certain situations, this book may be enlightening. However, if you’re struggling with jealousy, this book may be a solid pass for you.